Debate Seeks to Define Open Source Creativity

SAN FRANCISCO — Creative Commons, a movement and licensure protocol within the open source community, grants software developers the right to determine how and when their free code will be used, and this is stirring controversy.

The Creative Commons movement, spearheaded by Stanford professor Lawrence Lessig in 2003, advocates a public repository for code that can be used, modified and re-used, provided it is not deployed commercially.

This would allow developers to engage their creative sides without the burden of narrowing their vision to what would make money, advocates argue, saying that existing and emerging technology sparks creativity.

"When the power of creativity has been granted to a much wider range of creators because of a change in technology the law of yesterday no longer makes sense," Lessig wrote.

Opponents of the Creative Commons License, which is an opt-in designation, say that the license’s prohibition of commercial uses is needlessly limiting.

“A noncommercial site could distribute a million copies of something and that's okay, but a small commercial site cannot deliver two copies if it's for commercial purposes,” wrote John Dvorak in PC Magazine. “What is this telling me?”

The Open Source community’s standard license is known as the General Public License, which allows portions of code or discreet sections to be used in conjunction with other code for commercial purposes.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Missouri Lawmaker Attempts to Revive 'Health Warnings' for Adult Sites

A Missouri state representative has introduced a bill that would require adult sites to post notices warning users of alleged physical, mental, and social harms associated with pornography, despite a previous federal court ruling against such requirements.

New Age Verification Service 'BorderAge' Launches

French startup company Needemand has officially launched its subscription-based age verification solution, BorderAge.

Ruling: Italy's 'Porn Tax' Applies to All Content Creators

Italy’s tax revenue agency has ruled that the nation’s 25% “ethical tax” on income generated from adult content applies even to smaller independent online content creators.

Proposed New Hampshire AV Bill Appears to Violate Constitution

A bill in the New Hampshire state legislature, aimed at requiring adult sites to age-verify users in that state, contains a provision that seemingly contradicts the Supremacy Clause in Article VI of the U.S. Constitution.

AEBN Publishes Report on Fetish Trends

AEBN has published a report on fetish categories from its straight and gay theaters.

Online Child Protection Hearing to Include Federal AV Bill

A House subcommittee will hold a hearing next week on a slate of bills aimed at protecting minors online, including the SCREEN Act, which would make site-based age verification of users seeking to access adult content federal law.

Industry Photographer, 'Payout' Founder Mike B Passes Away

Longtime industry photographer and publisher Michael Bartholomey, known widely as Mike B, passed away Saturday.

FSC Announces 2025 Board of Directors Election Nominees

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has announced the nominees for its 2025 Board of Directors election.

AdultHTML Launches Black Friday Web Design, Development Promo

AdultHTML has launched its annual Black Friday/Cyber Monday promo for web design and development, running through Dec. 5.

Canada Exempts Online Adult Content From 'CanCon' Quotas

The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) has updated its broadcasting regulatory policies, exempting streaming adult content from “made in Canada” requirements that apply to other online material.

Show More